Skip to main content

Transplants: The right to choose your doctor, commerce in organs and the National Transplant Institute

There is an interesting article in Haaretz.  The article touches on three different aspects of organ transplants in Israel.  The first relates to a family that needed to transplant a lobe of liver from the father to his 1 year old baby girl.

Two weeks ago, the Shaked-Hadad family from Jerusalem returned home from Belgium. The family's 1-year-old daughter, Elinor, underwent a liver-lobe transplant in Brussels last December. The donor was her father. The operation abroad followed a struggle against the Clalit health maintenance organization, under the aegis of Kav Lachayim, an association that assists seriously ill children.

When she was born, Elinor was diagnosed with severe liver failure; her father was found to be a suitable donor. The Clalit HMO wanted the operation to be performed in Israel, but the family argued that liver-lobe transplants have a higher rate of success abroad and insisted that the operation be performed at Saint-Luc University Hospital in Brussels. 
I believe that this issue is unrelated to organ transplants.  It is a case where the parents decided that they did not trust the Israeli medical system and had to go elsewhere.  I don't understand why the Clalit HMO should have to cover any more of the costs then they would have covered in Israel.  There are successful liver transplants in Israel and it requires a well trained staff and facilities to provide this service.  If you explicitly agree that patients should go elsewhere, then why maintain facilities here?

My son had a transplant here and i do not believe he could have had any better care in the US or Europe.  The staff were first rate and the care equally good.  The offer by Clalit to fly in a doctor should have been a good compromise, but clearly the parents were already convinced to go elsewhere.  I'm surprised by the choice of hospital.  If you google for "liver transplant hospital", Saint-Luc is nowhere in the top 100 hits.  In fact, the most highly regarded facilities are in the US, so why choose Belgium?

The second part of the Haaretz article relates to commerce in organs:

The distress of Israelis in need of transplants has become more acute since the enactment of the Transplantation Law in May 2008. With commerce in organs formally outlawed, the HMOs stopped funding organ transplants for Israelis in many countries. At present, transplants are financed only in countries in which it is known that such commerce does not exist. The decision on underwriting transplants abroad is made by the HMO, on the basis of the patient's condition. But in the absence of clear criteria, authorization for transplant surgery abroad rarely comes without a struggle. 
Part of the problem is that Israel has a very low donor rate and hence is unable to participate in reciprocal relationships with European countries.  As a result, the easiest available organs are from  live donors (kidney and liver).    It used to be that people purchases a kidney on the black market and performed the transplant in eastern europe.  The new law forbids the HMOs from paying for transplants in countries that allow commerce in organs.

Finally, there is an ongoing story about National Transplant Institute in Israel.

Last year, only 282 transplant operations were performed in the country. Meanwhile, the National Transplant Center has been caught in the grip of a managerial crisis since the resignation of its chairman, Prof. Gavriel Gorman, several months ago. In his resignation letter, he noted, among other points, "I did not succeed in ensuring appropriate medical representation of the center in international medical organizations." 
The transplant institute is charged with two jobs; improving the quantity of available organs and managing the priority list for those waiting for a transplant.   I have not heard or read of any complaints regarding the priority list.  On the other hand, the number of organs from cadavers has fallen significantly in the past two years.  The reason I heard on the radio is that the new law requires a specific medical test with an approved testing machine to determine brain stem death.  It seems that some of the hospitals in Israel do not have these machines and hence cannot perform the tests.   In my view, donations for these machines should be on the top of philanthropic organizations wish lists.  Its a very easy way to save a life.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A change of pace (Kidney Failure)

I have been trying to keep this blog focused on hospitality and food.  God though has other plans for his creations and I find now that I will have to expand the scope to cover new topics.  I'll try to continue blogging about my menus and our guests, but expect more posts that have little or nothing to do with food. In February of this year, My second oldest son, Asaf was diagnosed with Chronic Renal Failure. Simply put, both his kidneys are damaged and scarred from some infection or defect that happened years ago.  They will likely cease to function sometime within the next six months. The good news is that there is no immediate danger to his life.  Kidney Dialysis is a viable option and can maintain his health for up to ten or more years if necessary.  Unfortunately, the process is not easy and there are potential side effects. Given Asaf's generally excellent health and age, Kidney Dialysis is considered only a stop-gap measure and not a long term solution. The best solutio

Unusual pesach meals part 2: Zupa Chrzanowa

What was I going to do with the horseradish root that I used for the pesach seder?  5 inches of spicy goodness.  Then I found this recipe for Zupa Chrzanowa,  Horseradish soup. I tried to keep close to the version in the link.  I made my vegetable stock from kitchen leftovers, carrot peels, onion skins, the green parts of leeks, celery and artichoke trimmings.  All parts that I would usually just throw in the trash.  They too contributed to my cooking today. Ingredients 1 carrot diced 1 stalk celery diced 1 onion diced 5 inches of horseradish (2 in diameter) grated 1 large potato diced 8+ cups of Vegetable stock 2 Tbsp olive oil Instructions Saute the carrot, celery and onion in hot olive oil until soft Add the diced potato, grated horseradish and vegetable stock (or water) simmer for 1-2 hours puree using an immersion blender or food processor Serve hot Update: Major failure.  The soup came out very very bitter and I'm pretty sure the culprit was the vegetab

TX +2 days

The transplant was on Monday afternoon. As I write this, its Wednesday afternoon. Call it 48 hours since my son received his new kidney. My wife and I are taking shifts at the hospital. She had the first night, I had the second. Tonight is her turn again. I just got back from the hospital and that's why there have been no posts. There is no Internet in the transplant ward. Medically, my Asaf is doing VERY well (as is the donor). When we went in, Asaf's creatinine level was about 6.4 mg/dL (GFR: 12). It means that his kidney was pretty much not doing anything. Today, we got the latest results. His new creatinine is 2.03 mg/dL (GFR: 46). That's better than my own and almost in the normal range (0.9 - 1.2 mg/dL). Each day its getting better and better. What this means is that his new kidney is working! He is able to eat a normal meal and is no longer on a restricted diet for kidney disease. This is great news! Our next hurdle is to make sure that his body does not reject the n